Chameth.com - posts like simple-backups-restic-hetzner, understanding-docker-volume-mounts but not debugging-beyond-the-debugger, docker-automatic-nginx-proxy, migrating-from-github-to-forgejo, why-you-should-be-using-https

The Case of the Unchanging Config

2026-04-09T00:00:00Z

Last week I was attempting to make it so I could share pictures on IRC directly from my client. This sounds simple, but it involves a bouncer¹ that proxies the request to a standalone image hosting service that I had to modify to be compatible. At one point my testing loop was:

Make a change to the hosting service
Commit it
Tag a new release
Wait for it to build
Update the version I’m running on my server
Reconfigure the bouncer to pass the new parameter or change the URL or whatever
Try uploading a photo from my phone
Realise I’ve overlooked something and go back to step one

I could have set up a local copy of everything and tested it sensibly. I should have set up a local copy of everything and tested it sensibly. But it seemed like such a trivial change, and setting up the whole environment seemed like such a pain. After the third or so iteration of failure I was pretty annoyed with myself, computers, and basically everything.

My biggest annoyance was that my bouncer would not pick up the new URL from the config when I changed it. It’s meant to reload the config when it receives a SIGHUP, and it claimed to in the logs, but I could clearly see it was still hitting the old URL. Restarting the bouncer to update the config is a pain, as it disconnects me from all the IRC networks, and has to reconnect to them all, reauthenticate, etc. It also mildly spams everyone who shares a channel with me².

When I finally got everything working I had a look at the bouncer source, and thought I’d spotted the issue. I raised a bug report, ending in this remark:

It looks like the config is reloaded properly, but the handler for uploads is created once at startup and has its own copy of the uploader, so effectively snapshots the config to whatever it is at startup:

fileUploadHandler := http.HandlerFunc(func(w http.ResponseWriter, r *http.Request) {
    cfg := srv.Config()
    h := fileupload.Handler{
        Uploader:    cfg.FileUploader,
        DB:          db,
        Auth:        cfg.Auth,
        HTTPOrigins: cfg.HTTPOrigins,
    }
    h.ServeHTTP(w, r)
})

I’m not quite sure what I thought I saw there, but that’s not right. I want to call it a hallucination, but that feels like a very overloaded word these days. I guess I was just seeing what I wanted to see, and that was a good excuse to stop investigating. Still, even if I misidentified the cause, the bug was still present, right? … Right?

The Science of Deduction

When the developer got back and said he couldn’t reproduce my issue, I went back to my install and immediately reproduced it. With a calmer head, I figured it was probably something with my particular set up. First thing to check: am I actually running the version I think I am?

Unfortunately the bouncer doesn’t actually seem to expose the version anywhere that I can see. It’s not in the logs, it doesn’t have a -version flag, and none of the IRC-based status commands seem to include it. But I know it’s a Go app, and I know Go embeds the version information. go version -m <binary> will dump it all out, but the binary is inside a Docker image, and the Docker image is one of my nice, minimal, artisanal ones so doesn’t ship a go binary. No problem, docker compose cp bouncer:/bnc ./bnc yoinks the binary out of the container, and then dumping the version shows that, yes, I am running the version I thought I was. Hmm.

The next tool I reached for in my toolbox was strace. Maybe it’s not actually reading the file for some reason? I immediately executed strace -p <pid> -e trace=openat,open,read,pread64 -f without having to look any part of that up. Yep. Definitely. Then I edited the config, HUP’d the bouncer, and saw that it was… reading the config file. As it’s meant to. By default strace truncates strings to 32 bytes, so I couldn’t actually see the line I’d changed. Some more definitely-not-RTFMing later, and rerunning it with an extra -s 65536 let me see the full config. Surprise! The config hadn’t changed!

To confirm my findings, I used docker compose cp again, this time yoinking the config file from inside the container. The inside config file was definitely different to the outside config file. What? My hypothesis at this point was “something something Docker nonsense”. I mount the config as read-only, and was wondering if that meant that Docker was doing something weird instead of just bind mounting it. A quick trip to /proc/<pid>/mounts showed that it was, in fact, not doing anything weird, and was just bind mounting it.

If the file is bind mounted, then surely it’s the same file? I ran stat on the file on the host, noted the inode number, then pondered how to actually run stat on the file inside the container, given the aforementioned awkwardly minimal image. The solution was easy: access it via /proc/<pid>/root/. I could’ve saved myself a bunch of docker compose cp if I’d thought about that earlier. Oh well. The inode of that file was different. What?

The answer was DNS. It’s always DNS. Oh, sorry, force of habit. I meant the answer was vim. I was editing the config in vim, and when it saves files, by default, it writes the new content to a temporary file and does an atomic rename. That’s normally a good thing: it prevents corruption if the write fails midway through³. In this case, though, that means the new file has a new inode. Bind mounting a file binds to the inode, so the container just keeps clutching onto the original config from when it was started, blissfully unaware that the party has relocated down the street.

This problem is likely to happen whenever you bind mount a file into a container. When I mentioned this to a friend, he immediately responded “oh yeah, never do that”, and went on to describe the horrible hacks he’s had to add to Ansible to sidestep the issue. The nicer solution is to just bind mount an entire directory if you can, as then it doesn’t matter what happens to the files within it. I really like having the config files sat alongside the Docker compose files, though; having to create a directory just to work around some bind mount weirdness upsets me.

Now I knew what the problem was, I found there was an issue raised against Docker twelve years ago⁴. The first response was “that’s expected”, and I fully agree with the author: “respectfully, that might be expected by you, but it was not expected by me”!⁵ As a result of the issue they added a nice note to the docs:

Note: Many tools used to edit files including vi and sed --in-place may result in an inode change. Since Docker v1.1.0, this will produce an error such as “sed: cannot rename ./sedKdJ9Dy: Device or resource busy”. In the case where you want to edit the mounted file, it is often easiest to instead mount the parent directory.

But in the intervening twelve years, both the note and the functionality described have gone missing. Ho-hum.

I found it interesting how I’ve only just hit this problem, given how long I’ve used Docker. But I realised that almost everything I run I’m happy to just restart. Cattle, not pets, and so on. My IRC bouncer is one of the few exceptions to that. The only other thing I regularly hot reloaded was Centauri, my reverse proxy, but that had a whole config directory mounted because it was shared between containers, so nicely sidestepped the foot-gun.

So lesson learnt: check for weird bind mount issues before raising issues about config hot reloading. It’ll join the esteemed company of “maybe the drive is full and causing completely unrelated problems?”, “perhaps everything is dog slow because the kernel ran out of entropy?”, and “did systemd sneakily take over that functionality while you weren’t looking?” in the troubleshooting checklist.

An IRC bouncer is basically an always-on proxy. It connects to the IRC networks for you, then your clients connect to your bouncer. The bouncer can then send incoming messages to all your different clients, cache them when you’re offline and replay them later, and lots of other nice things people take for granted in their chat apps these days. ↩︎
Join/part/quit spam is part of IRC, and clients have ways of handling it, but I still feel bad about doing it excessively. ↩︎
You can disable this in vim by setting backupcopy=yes. Good luck redoing all the debugging if you ever accidentally remove that from your vimrc, though! ↩︎
Which is weird, because Docker can’t possibly be that old. That would make me much older than I’m prepared to accept. ↩︎
If you read the thread they didn’t actually mean to sound so dismissive, but it’s still pretty funny. “Yes, it’s expected that the foot-gun causes your foot to hurt. Duh. What did you expect?” ↩︎

Thinking more about backups

2025-11-01T00:00:00Z

The Backblaze logo

Almost a year ago I wrote about how I do backups with Restic and Hetzner. That system has been ticking along well ever since, but recently I had some… thoughts. These backups are all well and good if I accidentally delete a file, or a database gets corrupted, or something, but there are two glaring issues:

Firstly, I’m backing up my Hetzner server to Hetzner cloud storage. If something happens to Hetzner — or my Hetzner account — then all my eggs go down with that basket. Obviously Hetzner are a big organisation and aren’t likely to just vanish overnight, but I’m less confident about my account. Could a false abuse report get it suspended? What if the UK passes even more dumb laws and Hetzner decide it’s easier just to not do business with people here? This is the same sort of concern I have about Google accounts: if you have half of your life in Google Drive and Google Mail, what happens if you comment on a YouTube video, get flagged by an AI moderation process, and your account gets suspended? It’s probably not very likely, but these are things my brain likes to dwell on.

Secondly, the credentials to access the backups sit on each machine that is backed up. If someone malicious gained access to the machine, they’d also have access to delete or tamper with all the backups. It feels a little silly that the same attack could take down both the originals and the backups. There’s no way to avoid that with Hetzner’s S3 implementation, as far as I can tell.

Exploring options

I toyed with the idea of making local copies of the backups, but the only way to avoid the same problems would be to keep them offline and do a manual copy every now and then. I didn’t really want to do that, and was concerned that if I did a monthly offline backup then I stood to lose up to a month of data in the worst case.

I then looked around at other S3 providers. Amazon’s glacier offering is tempting due to its very low storage costs, but you pay for that if you ever want to restore anything. There are also lots of weird pricing edge cases around moving data between storage classes, minimum file sizes, and so on. A much better option is Backblaze’s B2 product. Their pricing is much more straight-forward, and they have an interesting feature that’s particularly useful in this case: lifecycle rules. Coupled with the ability to create API keys that don’t have access to delete files (just “hide” them), this allows for what’s effectively an append-only store.

This works more-or-less out of the box with Restic. Joseph Price has a guide that goes into the setup in a bit more depth. Basically, whenever Restic would delete a file (e.g. during a “forget” or “prune” operation), it instead gets hidden and is only deleted when the B2 lifecycle rules decide it should be. I’ve kept the existing Hetzner S3 backups for now, and just added an extra step to the end of my script: a simple restic copy and a restic forget. B2 actually works out cheaper than the Hetzner storage, as they don’t bill you for a minimum of 1TB storage; my current usage is around $3/month. Not a bad price for some extra peace of mind!

Further Adventures in Music Organisation

2025-09-21T00:00:00Z

I wrote before about how I’d dropped Spotify in favour of locally stored music, but things have advanced a bit since. I had a few issues: Tauon would occasionally manage to lose its database and along with it all my carefully constructed playlists and song ratings¹, and the experience on my phone was not very fun.

I had to manually sync the music by plugging my phone in to the computer, and sometimes it just refused to mount the right partition. I don’t think there’s really a good way to debug an Apple phone not behaving properly when connected to a Linux desktop. Then I started wanting more than one playlist synced², and trying to find a way to make that work just broke me.

I spent a while looking at different ways of hosting the music centrally. Plexamp gets lots of good reviews, and I’ve used Plex a fair bit. I set about spinning up a Plex server, and just could not get it working. The server ran fine, served the web interface, but would neither associate with my account nor run standalone. The docs were contradictory and there was very little useful logging. After a lot of frustration, I stumbled across mentions that Plex block running on Hetzner. I assume that’s the cause of my issues, although I have no way to know for sure. I use Hetzner for all my servers and other hosted services, but Plex have decided I can’t run the self-hosted software that I have a lifetime subscription for there. What the actual fuck?

I could have probably worked around the arbitrary restriction, but I didn’t want to throw more time down the drain. Instead, I set up Navidrome, an open source music server. It supports the Subsonic protocol, which means you can use a whole slew of different clients with it (or even write your own). It also means there’s a nice way to get data in and out of it programmatically, which I recall being a bit of a fight with Plex.

Syncing and organising

All my music lived on my desktop, but now I wanted it on my server. At first I just used rsync to copy everything up. I’d maintain a local “master” copy, and periodically shove the changes to the server³. That quickly got old, so I set up Syncthing to keep the two folders in sync. That worked… for a while.

Concurrently, I was looking at improving the organisation of my music. It was mostly organised by some Go programs I’d thrown together to automate the importing, with no real validation of metadata or anything else. Some albums got split up into multiple folders because the tracks had different artists (and didn’t have an album artist set); some artists ended up with multiple folders with slight spelling or case variations. It was upsetting.

I’d used MusicBrainz Picard before to fix some issues, but I didn’t really like the UI, especially when trying to do bulk actions. The main alternative is beets, which describes itself as “the music geek’s media organiser”, and is entirely command line. I was intrigued.

I started playing around with beets, and quickly noticed a problem. Every time I changed a metadata tag in a music file, Syncthing had to upload the entire file. I was frequently changing tags across the whole library as I got beets set up how I wanted, and Syncthing was handling it by uploading gigabytes of files for every minor change. I was already a bit unhappy with having the content duplicated in two places, so now I was using a command line organiser I figured I could just get rid of my local copy and move everything to the server.

I set up a Docker container for beets, and then wrote some incredibly hacky shell scripts so I could run beet locally on my desktop and it would SSH to the server over Tailscale and exec into the container, passing the arguments along. Then I did one final sync of the music library, got rid of Syncthing, double checked I had a backup and deleted all of my local music.

Bears, Beets, Battlestar Galactica

Beets is amazing. It has a vast array of plugins that can do almost anything you could want with a music library, and the command line workflow works really well for me. It’s very well documented, and all the individual parts are pleasingly simple and easy to understand.

Here’s what it looks like when importing some new music:

Beets importing an album

If it doesn’t get a perfect match then it shows the closest matches, and summarises what’s different about them (missing tracks, different names, etc), and lets you decide what to do. Aside from the metadata matching, it’s doing a lot of things under the hood that aren’t necessarily apparent. It:

Looks up the genre from Last.fm
Analyses all the tracks and writes ReplayGain metadata to them
Fetches album art
Checks all the files to make sure they’re actually playable
Scrubs any existing metadata tags

It also maintains its own database, and you can query against it. The query language is both simple and quite powerful, like the rest of beets. As an example:

$ beet ls artist:"Linkin Park" year:2025 length:2:00..2:30 
Linkin Park - From Zero - Casualty

Almost all the other commands also let you use the query syntax, which makes the whole tool really powerful. Want to delete all country tracks that you added last month? No problem. Redownload all the album art for a certain band? Easy. You can even do smart playlists using the filters.

Actually playing music

With all this organisation, I’ve not actually mentioned one tiny detail: how I actually play music now. Navidrome has a web UI, which is perfectly usable, but I don’t really want my web browser involved as it makes balancing sound levels tricky, and getting media keys working is a pain. Thankfully there are loads of Subsonic clients. I’ve tried several, but eventually settled on Feishin on the desktop. It’s very pretty:

Feishin’s ’now playing’ screen

What attracted me to it, though, was its built-in support for Navidrome’s smart playlists. These aren’t even properly exposed in Navidrome’s web UI yet, but Feishin has a visual editor that lets you create and edit them. I ended up with an identical system to the playlists I had in Tauon: a “blacklist” playlist which are tracks I never want to play, a “favourites” playlist, and then an “everything” playlist which is the entire catalogue minus the blacklist.

On iOS I’ve settled on Arpeggi. It’s not actually on the App Store yet, but available via TestFlight. It’s one of those really nicely polished apps that are obviously a labour of love, not just out to do the minimum possible to get your money. It can cache songs offline, and automatically download entire playlists, and supports all of the standard Subsonic features like rating, reporting plays back to the server, and so on.

One unexpected benefit of using a central server is that it handles reporting plays to Last.fm and ListenBrainz instead of the clients. I don’t think I’ve ever bothered to configure my mobile clients to do that before, and now it just works automagically. I’m relying on those services more for recommendations and discovery, as that’s something you lose out on when self-hosting.

Making bad decisions about bitrates

With all the moving, copying, and organising, I started thinking about how large the collection was. The songs were all in different formats, depending on when and where I’d picked them up, and I couldn’t tell the difference between them. I did a test and transcoded an MP3 file down to 128kbps, and still couldn’t tell the difference. So armed with that sample size of 1, I transcoded the entire library and saved so much space.

I don’t remember which track I did that first test with, but it must have been a very unlucky pick. I quickly started to notice the distortions caused by the low bitrate. It was particularly bad in any song with a lot of treble, and started to really annoy me. I started a painful process of reimporting things in their original format. Beets came in clutch again, both with the import process (if you import a duplicate album, it asks if you want to replace the original, and shows the format and bitrate of them for comparison), and keeping track of what was left to fix (beet ls bitrate:..128000).

Having started paying more attention to the sound quality, I think I’ve been nibbled on by the audiophile bug. I’ve been trying to get new music in FLAC format where possible. I’m pretty sure I can’t tell the difference between a decent bitrate MP3 and a FLAC, but maybe if I got a better DAC and some nice headphones…? Someone please hide my credit card!

As for the library taking up a lot of space, I now realise it’s a price worth paying. I might need to swap out the server to one with more storage at some point in the future, but it’s generally worth upgrading every few years with rented dedicated servers anyway, as you often get more for the same amount of money. Next upgrade I’ll just make sure there’s an appropriately-sized disk instead of focusing entirely on RAM and CPU.

Writing more code

Naturally, this whole process spawned several side projects. When browsing albums in Navidrome, I was a bit upset that the album art wasn’t all a consistent size. I thought about scripting something to crop them consistently, but then I had a better idea, and jewelcase was born. It takes the album art, crops it down to a consistent size, and then renders it inside a jewel case. It applies some slight effects, like adjusting the colours, rounding the corners, and tweaking the edges so it looks a bit more real. I don’t know why⁴, but every time I see the effect it gives me a little spark of joy.

Album art, before and after jewelcase is applied

The other project is BASS, a tool that uses the Subsonic API to grab information about my music catalogue, and then generates a “Daily Mix” playlist. It uses a system of weights to select tracks semi-randomly, biasing towards favourite tracks, those that haven’t been played much, and a few other criteria. This gives me a nice balance between having my favourites on repeat, and exploring the full library at random.

All the weights in BASS are customisable, so I can tweak it to my heart’s desire, and anyone else can also run it and configure it entirely differently to me if they want to. I can’t imagine I would’ve been able to do that if I were using Plex!

I was running a version from git as the stable release had fun dependency issues on Arch, so it’s possible this wouldn’t be an issue in normal use. I also started backing up the database, but it’s still annoying to have to restore it. ↩︎
A “favourites” playlist for me, and a more “family friendly” playlist for when I’m playing music out loud that has a bit less screaming/swearing/etc. ↩︎
One of the reasons for starting this was being annoyed by the periodic sync to my phone, obviously it makes perfect sense to introduce a new, different periodic sync. ↩︎
Nostalgia? A little bit of OCD? Both? ↩︎

Simple backups with Restic and Hetzner Cloud

2024-12-06T00:00:00Z

Restic’s mascot, who’s dual-wielding umbrellas to save you from a rainy day.

I have a confession: for the past few years I’ve not been backing up any of my computers. Everyone knows that you should do backups, but actually getting around to doing it is another story.

Don’t get me wrong: most of my important things are “backed up” by virtue of being committed to remote git repositories, or attached to e-mails, or re-obtainable from the original source, and so on. I don’t think any machine failing completely would be a disaster for me, but it would certainly be a pain.

This week I finally got around to doing something, and it ended up being a lot more straight forward than my previous forays into backup-land.

Restic

After soliciting a few opinions, the choice of backup software came down to either Borg or Restic. I’m pretty sure either would have done what I want, but I leaned towards Restic for a few reasons: it has a more informative website, it’s written in Go rather than Python¹, and Borg seems to be transitioning between major releases at the moment².

The way Restic works is pretty simple: you initialise a ‘repository’, and can then call restic backup /some/path and it’ll get backed up to the repository. Restic handles keeping different backups separate, and only sending data that’s changed, and deduplicating, and so on. You basically point it at a thing you don’t want to lose, and it sorts it out for you. Perfect.

There are equally straight-forward commands for removing old snapshots (restic forget) and verifying backups (restic check). One of the nice things about modern backup solutions is they support a whole range of backends. I was originally going to spin up a small VPS to host my backups, but noticed that Restic supported S3-compatible stores…

Hetzner Cloud Object Storage

I host my servers with Hetzner, and was going to use them to spin up a VPS as well. Despite the “Cloud” branding on a bunch of products, they offer reasonable prices and good service. A couple of months ago, they started offering S3-compatible object storage.

The pricing isn’t totally straight forward, but for continuous use the “free quota” amounts to 1TB of storage and 1TB of egress a month. Ingress is free, as is traffic within the eu-central region (where all my servers are). That quota is only awarded when you pay the “base price”, though, which is €4.99 a month. So basically it’s €5 a month for 1TB of storage and enough egress to fully restore every single byte. That’s better value than any VPS I can find, much cheaper than Amazon S3, and about the same as Backblaze B2.

Getting them to work together

Now you’d think making the tool that supports S3-compatible object storage work with your S3-compatible object storage would be easy, right? Well not quite. The library Restic uses to deal with S3 backends has some strange logic for figuring out the bucket name given a URL. It doesn’t quite seem to work right, though…

Hetzner buckets have URLs like s3://bucketname.hel1.your-objectstorage.com³, but just passing that to Restic gives an error that the bucket is not specified. The docs mention there’s an advanced option to make it use the virtual host for the bucket name: -o s3.bucket-lookup=dns. But that… also doesn’t work. What I ended up doing was specifying the URL as s3://hel1.your-objectstorage.com/bucketname, and also passing in the dns option. The library then seems to muddle its way back to a real, working URL. I’m not sure why it works like this: maybe it’s just a weird aspect of S3 that I’m oblivious to?

The next fun part is that you can configure Restic entirely by using environment variables, except for that -o s3.bucket-lookup=dns argument. That has to go on the command line. I ended up making a little wrapper script to invoke Restic correctly:

#!/bin/sh

# The password restic will use to encrypt your data. You should generate
# something nice and secure.
export RESTIC_PASSWORD=repo-password

# The path to the repository where restic will save the backup. In our case
# this takes the form `s3:<endpoint>/<bucket>`. Your endpoint might be different
# to mine depending on the region your bucket is in.
export RESTIC_REPOSITORY=s3:hel1.your-objectstorage.com/bucket-name

# The access and secret key generated in the 'S3 credentials' section of the
# Hetzner Cloud Console
export AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID=hetzner-access-key-id
export AWS_SECRET_ACCESS_KEY=hetzner-access-key

# Pass any arguments on to the restic command, along with the magic
# `s3.bucket-lookup` option we need to resolve the S3 URL properly.
exec restic -o s3.bucket-lookup=dns "$@"

Then in the backup script I just alias restic to use the script:

#!/bin/bash

set -eu

# This means any time we use `restic` below, we'll actually execute our special
# script which supplies all the env vars and arguments needed to find the
# repository. Make sure the path matches where you saved the script!
alias restic='~/.bin/restic'

# Actually do the backup. Each directory in the list below will be backed up
# separately.
dirs=(
	"/some/path/to/backup/"
	"/some/other/path/"
)
for i in "${dirs[@]}" 
do
	echo $i
	(cd $i && restic --verbose backup .)
done

# Prune our snapshots. You can tweak the numbers here. Run with `--dry-run` to
# see what effect any changes would have before actually committing to them. 
restic forget --keep-daily 7 --keep-weekly 10 --keep-monthly 24 --keep-yearly 10

The only other notable thing here is that the script changes into the directory to be backed up. If you give Restic an absolute path, it will create a new snapshot if the metadata of any folder in the path changes, which is not what I want.

If it wasn’t for the S3 URL issues, the whole thing would’ve probably taken me about half an hour. That’s including setting up the object storage, installing Restic, and so on. It’s painfully easy. Why didn’t I do this three years ago?!

Addendum: a step-by-step guide

If you want to do this yourself, here’s a quick step-by-step guide:

Log in to the Hetzner Cloud Console, and create a project.
On the “Object Storage” tab, create a new bucket. Note the name and the endpoint.
On the “Security” tab, go to “S3 Credentials” and generate new credentials. Note down the access key and the secret key.
Copy the first shell script above, fill in the password (you can pick!), endpoint, bucket name, access key and secret key.
Run the script with the init argument (e.g. ~/.bin/restic init). This will create a new repository, and only needs to be done once even if you backup multiple machines.
Copy the second shell script above, making sure the restic alias points at the script you saved in step 4. Change the list of directories to whatever you want to backup.
Schedule the script to be run automatically, using crontab or systemd timers or however you prefer.

To check everything is working, you can use the snapshots subcommand to see a list of saved snapshots. You might also want to try to restore a snapshot using the restore subcommand.

I’m not trying to be a language snob, but given the choice between two otherwise equal projects one in Go and one in Python, I’ll take the Go one. I know I’m not going to have weird library issues down the line, and I’m much more comfortable rummaging around the source. ↩︎
With a “Don’t use this in production!” notice on the shiny new version. ↩︎
Aside: I really hate URLs like that. What is with the trend for completely generic domains divorced from the service they’re a part of? ↩︎

Understanding Docker volume mounts

2019-04-01T00:00:00Z

The Docker project logo

One thing that always confuses me with Docker is how exactly mounting volumes behaves. At a basic level it’s fairly straight forward: you declare a volume in a Dockerfile, and then either explicitly mount something there or docker automatically creates an anonymous volume for you. Done. But it turns out there’s quite a few edge cases…

Changing ownership of the folder

Perhaps the most common operation done on a Docker volume other than simply mounting it is trying to change the ownership of the directory. If your Docker process runs as a certain user you probably want the directory to be writable by that user.

At first we might try something like:

FROM alpine
RUN adduser -D -u 1113 test123
USER test123
VOLUME /testing

But changing the user doesn’t seem to have any effect on the volume. Why? Checking the docs for the USER instruction shows that only affects certain future operations — namely RUN, CMD, and ENTRYPOINT. It doesn’t affect the VOLUME instruction; if it did, you’d probably just get a permission denied error unless the user you switch to had privileges to create mount points.

OK, so instead we might try using the good old chown command:

FROM alpine
RUN adduser -D -u 1113 test123
VOLUME /testing
RUN chown test123 /testing

But again, the directory is just owned by root at runtime. Back to the docs, this time for the VOLUME instruction and towards the bottom is this little tidbit:

Changing the volume from within the Dockerfile: If any build steps change the data within the volume after it has been declared, those changes will be discarded.

As soon as Docker hits the VOLUME instruction the directory becomes a mount point, and anything we do to the temporary volume mounted there is discarded during the build process. So we have to change the ownership before the instruction, which may seem a little counter-intuitive:

FROM alpine
RUN adduser -D -u 1113 test123
RUN mkdir /testing && chown test123 /testing
VOLUME /testing

Now when the container runs, the /testing directory is owned by the test123 user. It’s not quite over, yet, though. This works if we let Docker create a volume automatically for us, or if we create a named volume and mount that; if we try and mount a host directory, though, it falls flat:

$ docker run --rm -it -v "$PWD/testing:/testing" testing ls -al /testing
total 8
drwxr-xr-x    2 1000     1000          4096 Apr  1 19:39 .
drwxr-xr-x    1 root     root          4096 Apr  1 20:44 ..

Docker handles mounting host directories differently to mounting volumes, even though the syntax is basically the same. Host directories are bind mounted directly into the container, so the permissions and ownership are the same as the directory on your host. The only way to fix them are to either change the permissions on the host, or have the container change them at runtime (assuming it has sufficient privileges).

One final wrinkle in all this happens when you use the same volume in multiple containers. Here we have two images built from the Dockerfile above, one with userid 1113 and one with userid 1114:

$ docker volume create testing
testing

$ docker run --rm -it -v testing:/testing testing1113 ls -nal /testing
total 8
drwxr-xr-x    2 1113     0             4096 Apr  1 19:49 .
drwxr-xr-x    1 0        0             4096 Apr  1 20:51 ..

$ docker run --rm -it -v testing:/testing testing1114 ls -nal /testing
total 8
drwxr-xr-x    2 1114     0             4096 Apr  1 20:47 .
drwxr-xr-x    1 0        0             4096 Apr  1 20:52 ..

$ docker run --rm -it -v testing:/testing testing1114 touch /testing/Hello

$ docker run --rm -it -v testing:/testing testing1113 ls -nal /testing
total 8
drwxr-xr-x    2 1114     0             4096 Apr  1 20:52 .
drwxr-xr-x    1 0        0             4096 Apr  1 20:53 ..
-rw-r--r--    1 0        0                0 Apr  1 20:52 Hello

$ docker run --rm -it -v testing:/testing testing1114 ls -nal /testing
total 8
drwxr-xr-x    2 1114     0             4096 Apr  1 20:52 .
drwxr-xr-x    1 0        0             4096 Apr  1 20:52 ..
-rw-r--r--    1 0        0                0 Apr  1 20:52 Hello

Can you see what’s going on? When the volume is empty, the ownership changes based on the mount point in the container. Once it has something in it, the ownership is fixed.

So Docker behaves differently with regard to permissions:

when the folder is mounted from the host vs a volume
when the volume is empty vs having content

Pre-populating mounts with files from the image

One of the more esoteric features of the way Docker handles volume mounts is that in some cases files from the image are copied over into the container. For example:

$ docker volume create testing
testing

$ docker run --rm -it -v testing:/etc testing sleep 1

$ docker run --rm -it -v testing:/tmp testing ls -al /tmp
total 184
drwxr-xr-x   15 root     root          4096 Apr  1 20:58 .
drwxr-xr-x    1 root     root          4096 Apr  1 20:59 ..
-rw-r--r--    1 root     root             4 Jun  7  2018 TZ
-rw-r--r--    1 root     root             6 Dec 20 21:31 alpine-release
...

The first container we run mounts the newly created testing volume at /etc. Docker copies all the existing files and folders into the volume; when we then run the second container with the volume mounted at /tmp, we can see all the files that were in the first container’s /etc.

As with permissions, this behaviour is anything but consistent. Say we switch from a volume to a host directory:

$ mkdir testing
$ docker run --rm -it -v "$PWD/testing:/usr/bin" testing sleep 1
$ ls -al testing
total 8
drwxr-xr-x 2 root  root  4096 Apr  1 22:05 .
drwxr-xr-x 3 chris chris 4096 Apr  1 22:05 ..

Nothing is copied in, and inside the container the folder will be empty. Based on our discoveries with permissions, it’s reasonable to assume the same will happen with a non-empty volume too:

$ docker volume create testing
testing

$ docker run --rm -it -v testing:/testing testing touch /testing/Hello

$ docker run --rm -it -v testing:/usr/bin testing sleep 1

$ docker run --rm -it -v testing:/tmp testing ls -al /tmp
total 8
drwxr-xr-x    2 root     root          4096 Apr  1 21:09 .
drwxr-xr-x    1 root     root          4096 Apr  1 21:09 ..
-rw-r--r--    1 root     root             0 Apr  1 21:08 Hello

So at least that’s consistent. If you’re very observant, though, you might notice I switched from /etc/ to /usr/bin in the examples. That’s because within the container /etc/ has some files bind-mounted into it, such as /etc/resolv.conf, and these do always result in files being created in the mounted volumes or folders:

$ mkdir testing
$ docker run --rm -it -v "$PWD/testing:/etc" testing sleep 1
$ ls -al testing
total 8
drwxr-xr-x 2 chris chris 4096 Apr  1 22:12 .
drwxr-xr-x 3 chris chris 4096 Apr  1 22:12 ..
-rwxr-xr-x 1 root  root     0 Apr  1 22:12 hostname
-rwxr-xr-x 1 root  root     0 Apr  1 22:12 hosts
-rwxr-xr-x 1 root  root     0 Apr  1 22:12 resolv.conf

Summary

Docker treats mounting host folders and mounting volumes differently. Don’t just assume that you can swap one for another and get the exact same behaviour.
Empty volumes will inherit permissions and files from the image they are mounted in; non-empty volumes and host folders will not.
Relying on Docker copying files into volumes is a very bad idea, as if you change those files in a future version of your image they will not be copied unless the volume is deleted and recreated.

I can’t find anywhere that these points are documented properly; if you know of anywhere, please drop me a message!